List Price: $649,000 | $236 per sq.ft. | 5 Bedroom | 2 Bathroom | 3 Story Single Family Home
Listed Tuesday Apr 21, 2026 | MLS# 5084567
14 Pleasant Street Plymouth NH
Listed by Anthony Castellano Lamacchia Realty, Inc.
Assumable FHA loan at 3.5% on ~$254K -- saving the buyer $466 per month, over $167,000 in interest over the life of the loan. This fully furnished, turnkey income-producing colonial sits right around the corner from Plymouth State University and the charming town center, nestled at the gateway to the White Mountains and Lakes Region. Currently operating as a proven student and young professional rental with an established rent roll, this expansive 5-bedroom, 2 full bath 1907 colonial offers 2,745 sq ft across three floors plus a 1,218 sq ft unfinished basement on 0.27 acres. Original coffered ceilings, corner fireplace, a light-filled sun-room and classic farmer's porch round out a property that is as livable as it is lucrative. Over $110,000 in documented capital improvements since 2022: full roof replacement; 200-amp panel upgrade; 36 new energy efficient windows; comprehensive kitchen remodel including new stainless appliances; two hyper heat pump systems; new water heater; two updated full bathrooms; refinished hardwood floors; fenced yard with patio and fire pit; newly paved driveway. A rare zoning advantage -- grandfathered legal nonconforming use confirmed by FHA-certified appraiser and Plymouth Building Inspector in 2022. With a stabilized NOI of $66,300 and a 10.2% CAP rate, this home is priced $183K below the certified rebuild cost of $832K. The detached 3-car garage and unfinished basement each represent potential significant ADU conversion opportunities -- with the ability to expand into a multi-unit income asset, subject to permitting. 1031 exchange and investor inquiries welcome.
Flooring: Carpet | Hardwood | Tile
Total Rooms: 10
Total Baths: 2
Full Baths: 2
Total Bedrooms: 5
Foyer: Room Dimensions: Floor: 1
Living Room : Room Dimensions: 14x15 Floor: 1
Sunroom : Room Dimensions: 8x9 Floor: 1
Kitchen : Room Dimensions: 13x26 Floor: 1
Dining Room : Room Dimensions: 7x12 Floor: 1
Bedroom : Room Dimensions: 11x10 Floor: 2
Bathroom Full : Room Dimensions: Floor: 2
Bedroom : Room Dimensions: 13x12 Floor: 2
Bedroom : Room Dimensions: 13x15 Floor: 2
Bedroom : Room Dimensions: 12x12 Floor: 2
Bedroom : Room Dimensions: 16x19 Floor: 3
Basement: Concrete Floor | Unfinished
Year Built: 1907
Type: Vinyl Siding

Building Info
Finished Sq.Ft.: 3963
Above Grade Sq.Ft.: 2745
Below Grade Sq.Ft.: 0
Apx Below Grade Unfinished Sq.Ft.: 1218

Exterior Info
Style: Colonial
Exterior Color White
Roof: Asphalt Shingle

Utilities
Electric: 200+ Amp Service | Circuit Breaker(s)
Water: Public
Sewer: Public

Land Description:
City Lot | Sidewalks
Lot size: 0.27 acres
Zoned: SFR
Surveyed: Unk
Flood Zone: Unknown
Seasonal: No
Driveway: Paved



Docs Available : Deed | Property Disclosure
Block - 111
Taxes $7,631
Assesed Value Not Reported
Schools
School District: Plymouth School District
Elementary School: Plymouth Elementary School
High School: Plymouth Regional High School

© 2000-2026 Clerkin Agency Real Estate
NEREN Logo
565 Maple Street, White River Junction, Vermont. 05001 802-295-1355
Copyright © 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated June 2nd, 2026

PLEASE NOTE: Both New Hampshire and Vermont law require brokers and agents to disclose at the “time of first business meeting, prior to any discussion of confidential information”, in New Hampshire’s case, and “first reasonable opportunity”, in Vermont’s case, the nature of the relationships brokers have or may have with customers and clients. Each state requires that a disclosure form be presented to consumers for their review and acknowledgment at the appropriate time. These forms can be accessed here:
VT: VERMONT REAL ESTATE COMMISSION MANDATORY CONSUMER DISCLOSURE FORM
NH: NEW HAMPSHIRE REAL ESTATE COMMISSION BROKERAGE RELATIONSHIP DISCLOSURE FORM